# Diffusion pipeline reliability — making the depth ControlNet actually followed

**Started:** 2026-06-15 · ongoing (`/loop`)
**Problem (user):** "controlnet maps generated are barely followed; images of the
dungeons are very hit and miss."

## Root cause found (iteration 1)

The FPV depth maps fed to the Z-Image Fun depth ControlNet used only a sliver of
the tonal range. Histogram over all 68 baked seed-7 frames:

- median dynamic range **193 / 255**, worst frame only **54**
- **0/68** frames reached true black (`<32`); the deepest recesses topped out ~mid-gray
- only **35/68** reached near-white at the near surfaces

Cause in `reikhelm-web/fpv.js`: a fixed `t = dpix / maxView` with `maxView = 12`.
The nearest floor sits ~1 cell away (never hit white) and a wall 3 cells ahead
landed at mid-gray (never black), so small rooms collapsed into the 160–214 band.
Depth ControlNets are trained on full-range MiDaS / depth-anything maps, so a
washed-out map gives almost no structural signal → the model freelances.

## Fix shipped — commit `018909b`

Two-pass raycast in `computeFPVDepth`:
- Pass 1 records each column's wall distance + the frame's true near/far.
- Pass 2 maps depth through a **per-frame window**: near → white, deepest visible
  recess → black, every frame.
- Far plane tracks the deepest *real* surface but is clamped to `minSpan` (5 cells)
  so a shallow dead-end nook is NOT stretched into a fake tunnel — its faced wall
  stays an honest mid-gray slab (no black recess → no phantom-door bait).
- `gamma` 2.0 → 1.5 (normalization now owns the range). `nearPlane`/`minSpan` are opts.

**Verified offline** (headless `bakeAtlasDepths(7)`, 68 frames):
median range 193 → **255**; near-white frames 35/68 → **68/68**; worst range 54 → 106.
Visual before/after (`/tmp/ba.png` during the session): open frames now frame a
black passage; closed frames a clean mid-gray wall.

## Next — needs the render workstation (192.168.1.26:8188, was OFFLINE this iteration)

The depth signal is now strong, so the old strength is almost certainly wrong.
With a weak signal you crank strength to force adherence; a strong signal wants
*less*. `bake_atlas.py` defaults `--strength 0.85`.

1. Re-probe the workstation: `python3 tools/comfy-spike/comfy.py probe http://192.168.1.26:8188`
   (2026-06-15 iter 2: host pings but **port 8188 closed — ComfyUI not running**; needs a
   manual start on the workstation before any of the below.)
2. **A/B + strength sweep in one run** (tool written & validated; old rev-2 maps persisted
   to `tools/out/compare/rev2_depths/` so the fix is provable, not just "looks better"):
   ```
   python3 tools/comfy-spike/sweep_strength.py http://192.168.1.26:8188 \
       --seed-dir tools/out/atlas/7 --alt-work tools/out/compare/rev2_depths \
       --open r8_N --closed r0_N --strengths 0.55,0.7,0.85,1.0
   ```
   → `tools/out/compare/sweep_<run>.png`: each frame gets a NEW row (full-range maps) and
   an OLD row (washed-out rev-2) across every strength. Read adherence: does the rendered
   passage land on the black recess? does the closed wall stay a wall (no phantom door)?
   Expect NEW ≫ OLD; pick the lowest strength that still honors geometry, update
   `bake_atlas.py --strength 0.85` default. (Drop `--alt-work` once the win is confirmed.)
3. Then re-bake a full atlas at the chosen strength and spot-check a montage vs the
   old `acc8137`/`a12bcbb` bakes.

## Iteration 3 — first GPU pass (2026-06-15/16, workstation back up)

Ran the A/B + strength sweep (16 renders) and follow-ups. Findings:

1. **Open frames: the rev-3 normalization works.** `r8_N` renders a clean pillared
   hall with the passage landing exactly on the depth's black recess. NEW ≈ OLD here
   only because `r8_N` already had structure; the win shows on small-room recesses.
2. **Blown-highlight regression (introduced by rev-3, now FIXED).** Mapping the
   nearest pixel to pure white (`nearPlane = nearRaw`) made the ControlNet render
   overexposed near floors/ceilings at strength 0.85. Fix: `nearPlane = 0` (anchor
   white at the camera, nearest real surface ≈ gray 214) + `minSpan = 8`. Re-baked +
   re-rendered: blown ceiling gone, geometry adherence intact, recesses still black.
3. **Phantom doors on closed walls = a PROMPT problem, not depth.** Present in OLD
   maps too. Root cause: opening-NOUNS in the positive prompt. `threshold`'s body
   ("dungeon gatehouse, iron portcullis, entrance") painted a gate onto a solid
   wall; at cfg 1.0 the negative can't cancel it. A generic opening-free body
   ("rough-hewn stone chamber, bare granite walls") renders a clean dead-end.
   "Bricked-up archway" BACKFIRES — "archway" alone re-summons the arch.
   → Fix in `bake_atlas.py`: `THEME_BODY_CLOSED` (theme flavor, zero opening nouns)
   for closed facings + opening-nouns added to the negative on closed facings only.

**Tooling fixes:** `sweep_strength.py` re-exec-under-venv guard (the venv's python is
a symlink to the base interpreter, so the realpath check wrongly skipped the hop —
now an env-sentinel guard); montage now succeeds in one invocation.

### Iteration 3 end-to-end result — VALIDATED ✅
Full seed-7 re-bake (67/68; one transient ComfyUI miss, re-rendered) through rev-3
maps + closed-body prompts. Old-vs-new montage (`tools/out/compare/`):
- **r0_N (threshold, closed):** OLD painted a grand gateway + portcullis on a solid
  wall; NEW renders a clean ashlar wall with torches. Phantom door gone.
- **r16_E (throne, closed):** clean wall with banners/columns — theme flavor survives
  with zero opening nouns. Generalizes past threshold.
- **r16_N (throne, open) / r8_N (hall, open):** rich themed scenes, passage exactly on
  the depth recess. Forge lava / crypt sarcophagi / library shelves / den all good.
- Strength **0.85 kept** — honors geometry without stiffness on the high-contrast maps.

### Campaign upgrade (in progress)
DESCENT loads these atlases directly (`game.js setFrame /out/atlas/<seed>/r<room>_<dir>.png`).
Campaign = seeds **7, 69, 59** (`game-web/game.js CAMPAIGN`), all previously baked at
the broken rev-2 (`a12bcbb`). Seed 7 done. Re-baking 69 + 59 through rev-3 (depths
re-exported headless, old frames backed up to `compare/old_bake_<seed>/`).

## Iteration 4 — QA sweep + strength tune (2026-06-16)

Systematic QA of all 208 baked campaign frames (not just spot-checks):
- **Closed walls (83): zero phantom doors.** Ranked every closed frame by
  center-vs-flanking-wall darkness; even the worst (r6_W forge, r11_E crypt, r0_W
  den) are genuine solid walls — the dark center is lighting falloff / a real
  stone mass, not a recess. The closed-body prompt fix holds campaign-wide.
- **Open frames (125): median 0.18%% blown.** Low-contrast flags were false
  positives (atmospheric dark throne halls). One real pattern: deep-corridor
  frames — mostly **crypt** — blew out a white ceiling band at the top edge
  (r9_N 27.7%%, r13_N 21%%, r11_N 18%%).
- **Root cause + fix:** the depth's near-ceiling top edge is gray ~209 (bright);
  at strength 0.85 the ControlNet forced it to overexposed white, amplified by
  crypt's "pale light". GPU A/B on r9_N: **strength 0.70 → 0.0%% blown** (vs 27.7%%
  at 0.85) with geometry intact; de-paling the prompt did nothing (cfg-1 negatives
  inert). Verified r0_N closed wall stays solid at 0.70 → one global strength is
  safe. **Set `bake_atlas.py --strength 0.85 → 0.70` (commit b661989).** Campaign
  re-baked at 0.70; 0.85 frames archived under `tools/out/compare/str85_<seed>/`.

### Optional later
- The single-frame retry-on-empty in bake_atlas would avoid the occasional ComfyUI miss.

## Open levers if still hit-and-miss after strength tuning
- `nearPlane`/`minSpan`/`gamma` are now tunable per-export — A/B if near surfaces
  read too blown-out (the AFTER maps are ~47% near-white; may want a slightly
  deeper nearPlane to retain near-field texture).
- Subtle masonry-block relief on closed-wall slices so flat walls render as detailed
  stone (offline-buildable, but verify on GPU it doesn't read as structure).
- Strength `start_percent`/`end_percent` scheduling (currently 0→1 full) — easing
  control off in late steps frees texture while locking composition.